November 16, 2026

Arguments of Ignorance VIII: A Roadside Tavern

Acts 28:15: "From there the brothers, when they heard of us, came to meet us as far as the Market of Appius and The Three Taverns. When Paul saw them, he thanked God and took courage."

Luke mentions ancient, long forgotten markets and taverns. Why would Luke put such mundane facts in such an important book like the Bible? Because as Luke 1:1 says it is because he, “carefully investigated everything from the beginning, I too decided to write an orderly account for you, most excellent Theophilus.” He was writing an ordered and accurate account of everything that had happened before and after Jesus’ resurrection.

At the end of Acts, Paul is marched under guardup the great road to Rome. Believers from the citywalk out to meet him at two places: the Market of Appius, and the Three Taverns. People that don’t believe in Christianity often call Acts a novel. Ironically, Roman road guides list both stops on that road, at the right distances from Rome. ARoman poet who made the same trip complained about the Market of Appius. It was crammed with boatmen and stingy innkeepers. A famous Roman statesman mentions both places in his letters. The road itself is still there, stone by stone. It is clear to the author of Acts that these places existed…because Luke traveled these paths.

The Forum Appii ("Market of Appius") was located about 43 Roman miles from Rome on the Via Appia, at the north end of a canal through the Pontine Marshes; Tres Tabernae ("Three Taverns") lay about 33 miles out. Both are listed on the Antonine Itinerary (Itinerarium Antonini Augusti) which was an ancient itinerarium or a register of stations and distances along Roman roads. It is thought to be based on official documents, possibly from a survey under Augustus, likely compiled under Diocletian.

They are also on the Peutinger Table (Tabula Peutingeriana) is an illustrated itinerarium, a narrow, scroll-like map of the Roman road network (cursus publicus). The surviving parchment copy dates to c.1200 and is a medieval reproduction of a Late Antique original, possibly based on a 4th–5th century map derived from Agrippa’s early imperial world map. A 2012-2013 survey traced the road station at Forum Appii near Borgo Faiti. Horace (Satires 1.5.3-4) describes Forum Appi as "crammed with boatmen and stingy innkeepers," and Cicero names Appii Forum and Tres Tabernae in his letters to Atticus (2.10, 2.12).

An honest counter argument could be made though. The Appian Way was famous, so any writer could name its stops. The interesting part about the narrative though is Luke additionally names two small way stations, in the right order and two groups of believers at different distances, in the "we" section of Acts, where the writer says he was with Paul. The truth is this…it reads like the sequential entry diary or travelogue of a traveler, not a novelist's backdrop.

Luke’s method matches his stated Prologue in Luke 1:1-4: he writes as a companion-observer (the "we" sections of Acts) who pays close attention to nautical terms, administrative titles (such as proconsul or polytarch), and physical geography. In the ancient Mediterranean world, inventing roadside stops that real travelers would immediately recognize as out of sequence or fake would discredit an account. Instead, the real-world grit of the Pontine Marshes, the cramped roadside shops (tabernae), and the precise mileage underscore that the early church grew within actual, mappable Roman history..

No comments: